Types of Electronic Signature: Typed, Drawn, Click, Certificate
Tools offer a handful of ways to sign. They differ in what they record and how much protection they add. None is the "real" one.
Typed name
You type your name, and the tool shows it in a script-style font. That's all.
Courts in England and Wales have accepted "a name typed at the bottom of an email" in some situations.1 They judge intent by taking "an objective approach considering all of the surrounding circumstances."1 A typed name works when the facts show you meant it.
Drawn mark
You draw with a finger, a mouse or a stylus. The tool saves the image of your mark.
This is the closest cousin to ink. Wikipedia says courts in various places have treated "signing a credit or debit slip with a digital pen pad device" as enforceable.2 The tool is capturing a picture. On its own, that picture isn't tied to the file by math.
Click to accept
You tick a box or press a button that says you agree.
Wikipedia lists a "clickwrap software license agreement" among agreements courts have treated as enforceably signed in some jurisdictions.2 Clicking is quick, and it suits low-stakes forms.
Certificate-based
This type uses a digital certificate, which is an electronic ID that vouches for a key held by the signer. One vendor guide says these tie a signer's identity to a signature using public key infrastructure.3
The signature is also "mathematically bound to the content of the message," so later changes to the file can be spotted.4 The page on electronic versus digital covers the idea in more detail.
Named levels you'll see in some countries
Some places write levels into law. For an advanced electronic signature, Wikipedia lists a common test. The signer must be uniquely identified and linked to the signature2.
It adds that some countries, such as member states of the European Union and Switzerland, "introduced the qualified electronic signature" for stronger proof.2
These levels don't apply everywhere. In the US the page says a qualified electronic signature isn't defined.2 If a contract or regulator names a level, read the exact wording.
A side-by-side look
| Type | How it's made | What it leaves behind |
|---|---|---|
| Typed name | Letters typed, shown in a font | A typed name1 |
| Drawn mark | Finger, mouse or stylus | An image of the mark2 |
| Click to accept | Tick box or button | Agreement to the terms2 |
| Certificate-based | Keys and a digital certificate | Data bound to the file4 |
Choosing between them
You're not choosing the "real" one. You're choosing how much evidence a document needs.
- A simple internal approval may be fine with a click.
- A customer contract may call for a name plus a log of who signed and when.
- A document that a regulator or another party says must carry a certificate-based signature needs that type, whatever else you'd prefer.
Check what the other party, the law or your industry asks for before you pick. A tool's marketing page isn't the place to find out. The legal overview points to official sources.
Where the facts come from
- Electronic execution of documents, Law Commission (England and Wales)
- Electronic signature, Wikipedia
- Electronic signature authentication, Docusign
- Digital signature, Wikipedia