Are Electronic Signatures Legally Valid? A General Overview
Often, yes, but not always, and it varies by country and by document. This page is general information, not legal advice.
United States
Federal law says a signature can't be denied validity "solely because it is in electronic form."1 The word "solely" matters. It stops a signature being thrown out just for being electronic. It doesn't promise that every other test is met.
Two more points from the same law:
- Nobody has to say yes. No one is forced to accept e-signatures.1
- Other laws that set their own rules about rights and duties still apply.1
States have their own laws too. Wikipedia lists the Uniform Electronic Transactions Act as "adopted by 48 states."2 That page is a general listing, so check your state's own law for details.
England and Wales
The Law Commission is an official law-reform body. It says electronic signatures "are validly used" instead of handwritten ones "every day."3 It adds that one "is admissible in evidence in legal proceedings."3
Here's where it gets specific. The same source says a deed must be signed in the physical presence of a witness who attests the signature, even where electronic signatures are used.3 Its report also says it does not extend to wills.3
Scotland and Northern Ireland weren't covered by that source. Ask a local lawyer.
Australia
The Commonwealth's Electronic Transactions Act 1999 is on the Federal Register of Legislation. Its contents list a general rule about the validity of electronic transactions for Commonwealth laws, and a part on requirements under those laws.4 The saved page shows the contents list only, so read the Act itself on that site. State and territory rules need their own check with the relevant government or a lawyer.
Canada and the European Union
Wikipedia says Canada's PIPEDA defines a generic electronic signature and then a more specific "secure" one. In the European Union, a regulation known as eIDAS "sets the legal frame for electronic signatures," with named levels such as advanced and qualified.2 It also notes the US has no defined qualified signature2.
Those are summaries from a general reference page. For anything binding, go to the legislation itself or ask a local lawyer.
Why your case may differ
Wikipedia puts the whole problem in one line: "Definitions of electronic signatures vary depending on the applicable jurisdiction."2 Three things change the answer:
- Where you and the signer are.
- What the document is. Deeds and wills often have extra formalities.
- Who else has rules, such as a bank, landlord or regulator.
Where to look
Start with the official source for your country. In the US that could be your state's legislature site, the Federal Trade Commission's business pages or an attorney. In the UK, the Law Commission and GOV.UK. In Australia, the Federal Register of Legislation and the Attorney-General's Department. In Canada, the federal and provincial justice sites.
Then bring your actual document to a lawyer. This site can explain how tools work. It can't tell you your signature will hold up.
A practical note: keeping the signed file and its record together helps you answer questions later. And for what counts as a signature at all, see What Is an Electronic Signature?
Where the facts come from
- 15 U.S. Code § 7001 - General rule of validity, Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
- Electronic signature, Wikipedia
- Electronic execution of documents, Law Commission (England and Wales)
- Electronic Transactions Act 1999, Federal Register of Legislation (Australia)